The Death of Comic Books

Written by Martin Shapiro on Friday, 09 November 2012. Posted in Publishing

The Death of Comic Books

Due to a recent string of popular Hollywood blockbusters that were based on comic books, the market for comics and graphic novels has maintained respectable sales numbers for certain well-known superhero titles. According to Nielsen BookScan, which tracks retail book sales, graphic novel sales in U.S. bookstores have grown in recent years. Bookstores have devoted more and more shelf space to graphic novels, bound collections, and manga.

Marvel's trade paperback division has tripled sales over the past year, while DC Comics' trade paperback unit is the fastest growing in its publishing group.

Despite this growth spurt in graphic novels, the American comic book industry as a whole is still a fraction of Japan’s huge manga market, which is estimated at about $6 billion. Why the huge difference in unit sales? In short, the Japanese culture has embraced visual storytelling in print. Anime and manga includes stories from all walks of life, from school kids to romance to sports, while in America, the only enduring characters coming out of the big American publishers are traditional superheroes. In fact, 80% of the domestic direct market sales are still superhero books.

Couple that with the fact that many young people in America today don’t read as much as they did in previous generations. They are not familiar with the comic book format. The American comics industry does not use mass-market forms of advertising to promote its products like movie studios and video game companies do. You will never see a new comic book title advertised on TV, or on billboards along a city street. That is why comic books have remained an insular small niche market.

Another key factor limiting growth is the relative difficulty for the average would-be consumer in finding a convenient comic book retail store in the local community. With less than 1500 viable comic shops nationwide, it's hard for your average person to just stumble across a comic book these days while out shopping.

Comic books also have a lot of leisure activities to compete with now. Call it progress, or evolution, but with video games and the Internet assuming more of a role in today's entertainment market, books have taken a back seat on the entertainment bus.

Nowadays, comic books have evolved into a development springboard for other, more lucrative avenues of future income, primarily from licensing the movie rights. Creators and publishers who embrace this new reality can prosper. Those still locked in the era of nostalgia, where printed comic book sales alone could keep you in business, will wither away.

About the Author

Martin Shapiro

Martin Shapiro

Martin Shapiro created the horror comic book series Chopper, and sold the movie rights to it. The prequel to Chopper was produced as a web TV series starring Tyler Mane (Halloween, X-Men). Mr. Shapiro’s action-thriller screenplay Lair of the Fox was optioned by Ilya Salkind (Producer of Superman). Mr. Shapiro has written and developed projects for MGM, HBO and numerous production companies including an adaptation of Dragonlance, the New York Times bestselling series of fantasy novels with sales of 22 million copies. He received a Master’s Degree in Screenwriting from UCLA and now teaches classes at New Hampshire School of Film and Television.

Leave a comment

Please login to leave a comment.


The Graphic Novel Creator Playbook is a compilation of the month's best articles and featured artists. Get exclusive tips and tricks from comic book professionals in your inbox every month.

* indicates required

Affiliate Program

Your mission today, should you choose to accept it, is to tell your industry friends about Graphic Novel Creator. Spread the word and it'll be good karma! Tweet about us on Twitter or share the website link on Facebook.

And, if you're really stoked about Graphic Novel Creator or one of its classes, join our affiliate program so you can earn money from your tweets! Help support the website so we can continue to upgrade it and provide valuable information to help you publish your books.

Learn More